Why You Might Hesitate to File Small Claims in Insurance

When it comes to managing insurance, the decision to file a claim, especially for smaller issues, can be surprisingly complex. While insurance is designed to provide financial security against losses, not every loss warrants a claim. Here are compelling reasons to think twice before filing small claims with your insurance provider.

1. Potential Increase in Premiums

One of the most significant consequences of filing a claim is the potential increase in your insurance premiums. Insurers assess risk based on the frequency and severity of claims made. Even if a claim is small, it can flag you as a higher risk to insurers. As a result, this could lead to higher premiums over time. For many policyholders, the long-term cost of increased premiums can outweigh the immediate benefits received from a small claim settlement.

2. Loss of No-Claims Bonus

Many insurance companies offer a no-claims bonus as a reward for claim-free years. This bonus usually translates into a discount on your premiums, which can accumulate to substantial savings over time. Filing a small claim might cost you this bonus, leading to a direct financial penalty that could exceed the amount of the claim itself.

3. Deductibles Eating into Claims

Deductibles — the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance kicks in — are a crucial factor in deciding whether to file a claim. For small claims, the deductible might cover a large portion or even exceed the total cost of the damage or loss. In such cases, the financial benefit of filing the claim is minimal, and handling the expense independently could be more economical.

4. Impact on Future Coverage

Filing frequent small claims can not only increase your current insurance costs but also affect your ability to secure insurance easily in the future. Insurers might view a history of many small claims as indicative of carelessness or an increased likelihood of larger claims, which could lead to difficulty finding affordable insurance or even denial of coverage.

5. Time and Effort Vs. Reward

The process of filing an insurance claim involves paperwork, time, and often, stress. For smaller claims, the effort required to navigate this process might not seem worth the potential payout. Policyholders must consider if the time and effort invested could be better spent elsewhere, especially when the financial recovery after deductibles is marginal.

6. Preserving Insurance for Major Incidents

Insurance is ideally a safety net for significant financial losses that are difficult to recover from without assistance. Utilizing your policy for minor issues might compromise your coverage when you need it most. For instance, if your policy limits the number of claims you can make in a certain period, saving your claims for more substantial losses is a strategic approach.

7. Risk of Policy Cancellation

While not common, it’s possible for an insurance company to decide not to renew a policy if they perceive a customer as too high-risk due to frequent claims. This risk of cancellation is another factor to weigh, especially if your claims history might paint an unfavorable picture of your risk profile.


Filing a claim for every small loss might seem like a good use of your insurance; however, the long-term consequences such as increased premiums, loss of no-claims bonuses, and the potential impact on future coverage should make you think twice. Assessing each situation carefully and considering whether the claim is financially justifiable not only preserves your insurance for more significant incidents but also helps maintain your premiums at a reasonable rate. Therefore, while the protection offered by insurance is invaluable, prudent use of this resource is crucial for your financial health.

Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at Millennium Brokers is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Call Email Claims Payments